Market
The stock market's return over Treasury bills.
How profitable is a firm? The answer depends on the comparison. The standard factor model compares every firm with the whole market. I compare each firm with its closest peers, identified from the text of regulatory filings, and find that investors are paid for the difference.
I thank Professor Eugene F. Fama for his valuable feedback over the Spring 2026 quarter of the Research Projects: Finance seminar at the University of Chicago, and the other students in the seminar for their comments.
Compared to whom?
↓→Scroll or use the arrow keys. Each step adds one piece of the argument.
The example opens the paper. The peer margins shown here are illustrative.
The stock market's return over Treasury bills.
Small firms minus large firms.
High book-to-market minus low.
Robust minus weak operating profitability.
Low asset growth minus high.
A schematic. I show the real split for the paper's factor under “The result”.
Twelve hypothetical firms. Figures are profit margins in percent, chosen for illustration.
Redrawn from Figure 1 of the paper, which names five of the 25 peers.
The profitability a firm shares with others facing the same demand, costs and regulation. RMW prices mostly this part.
What remains once the peer median is removed. The five-factor model has no factor for it.
This analysis is new and does not appear in the paper. I computed it from the paper's monthly peer files, using June snapshots from 1996 to 2025 and NYSE size breakpoints. The appendix describes the method.
Filings read: 297,827 annual 10-Ks and 731,470 quarterly 10-Qs
Dimensions in each firm's embedding
Peers per firm, by cosine similarity, refreshed monthly
Firm, peer, month observations across thirty snapshots
Share of a focal firm's 25 peers in each SIC division. Rows sum to 100%.
Hover or tap a marker for the event.
Five-factor alpha per year. t = 5.00. Sharpe ratio 0.78.
Five-factor alpha per year. t = 3.39. Sharpe ratio 0.73.
Percent per year. The 4.7% is the paper's mean monthly return of 0.39%, annualized.
When firms are ranked against the whole market, profitability mostly shows which industry each one is in. Once they are ranked against peers identified from filing text, with no look-ahead, the ranking picks up how well each firm is run. The five-factor model has no factor for that part, and adding one improves it. The same peers can now be applied to every other characteristic investors use to rank firms.
Celik, Neil. 2026. “Profitability, Relative to Peers: Text-Identified Reference Groups and the Cross-Section of Returns.” Working paper, The University of Chicago Booth School of Business, June.
The numbers behind the figures, and a description of how I ran the firm-size analysis.
This analysis is new and does not appear in the paper. It uses the paper's own monthly peer files, which list each firm's 25 peers every June from 1996 to 2025.
The measure is the total-variation distance between the two-digit SIC mix of a firm's peers at two dates. I hold each peer's industry label fixed, so the measure moves when the set of peers changes. Size groups use New York Stock Exchange breakpoints: smallest is below the 20th percentile of market value, small is the 20th to the 50th, large is above the median.
A new model is trained each year, so some of the change comes from the model and some from the business, and this measure cannot separate the two. The comparison across sizes is unaffected, because every size group is read by the same models. At ten years the smallest-minus-largest difference is −0.4 points with a firm-clustered standard error of 0.7.
The four small firms shown in Fig 8 were chosen as clear illustrations from firms that stayed below the NYSE median size in every year observed. Among 1,326 such firms with at least 15 years of history, 17% had more than half of their peer mix replaced between their first and last three years.